via: black china hand, read the post: 胡说八道(rubbish talk)
in that wired news article:
Mao dismisses that statement as disingenuous. The company, he says, is going above and beyond official censorship practices, which deal decisively with speech critical of the ruling communist government, but don’t outright ban words like “freedom. They could try to reach a balance, so the users will understand, but the government won’t try to make trouble for the business,” says Mao. “Instead, they’re just trying to flatter the government.”
mr. black china hand has a different opinion:
I’m no Microsoft fan but is this Mao guy serious. Microsoft is doing what any cautious business in China would be expected to do…eliminate the risk that the CCP will pull the plug on them. (Microsoft is not the only company that follows this unwritten rule and the rule is not confined to just technology…for example schools “self-censor” texts as do news media with any “risky” stories.) If anything you have to applaud Microsoft for “learning the realities on the ground” and applying it to their business model. As the saying goes…the nail the sticks up gets hammered. Accordingly, any “revolt” against the rules are not going to come from a company that has money to lose but from individual bloggers waging a guerilla campaign outside the government’s and big businesses ambit. That’s where Mr. Mao can help the most…blaming Microsoft for caving in accomplishes nothing.
TBC...
let me elaborate my points here - i am not supporting the ban of any nice words on the web (as mr. asiapundit misinterpreted me). labeling something you don't like as "evil" is quite easy, how to make things move and advance requires something more than simplistic labeling ("evil"), confrontational criticisms (like some media commentators did) or merely an escape (the levi case), it requires patience, wisdom and "change-seat perspectives". now you ask me what's my point, simple, let MS Spaces compromise and in, to help young people learn independent and critical thinking, to foster a culture in which people tolerate and benefit from different voices (in MS Spaces), to contribute to the local communities and prove MS is a positive power, not a danger to social stability, to create a virtuous circle and therefore detoxify the me-you and black-and-white mentality (existing in both chinese and western sides). all these, and much much more, are valuable work for MS to do and are important for chinese as well. let's boil the water from 60 C to 70 C, then from 70 C to 80 C, don't waste time chanting 100 C water makes best tea (everybody knows that!), someday when the water is 99 C, then it's the time Mr. Isaac Mao should appear in the scene.
note: i don't have problem with isaac personally, he is a cool guy with a moustache and looks very smart when he appears on tv, maybe i should have a isaac-style moustache to make myself look more "mature" :)
china