Wednesday, June 29, 2005

from hunan

from chengdu

from hangzhou

not sure what's wrong with their eyes

posted @ 8:15 PM

via: mutant frog, read the post: Henry Kissinger doesn’t know Chinese history (or maybe just lies about it)

to refute Dr. Kissinger's assertions that "Military imperialism is not the Chinese style." and that "The Chinese state in its present dimensions has existed substantially for 2,000 years.", mutant frog gives us a map of Han dynastry of china:

han dynasty china

obviously it's more than enough to retort the second assertion of " ...in its present dimensions has existed substantially for 2,000 years", but let's see if it's enough to retort the two assertions with another two maps of china.

map of china, yuan dynasty

map of china, qing dyansty

if you only regard "Han people" as the "chinese people", actually most of the territories like tibet, mongolia were seized by manchus or mongolians, not by "chinese people", therefore, it is true that "Military imperialism is not the Chinese style"

if you also include manchus and mongolians as part of "chinese people", then the first map mutant frog gives us is quite misleading in representing the "map of china", and the "chinese state" that includes the territories of manchus and mongolians and tibetans certainly "has existed substantially for 2,000 years", therefore, it is true that "Military imperialism is not the Chinese style" (in fact except a few sporadic periods)

well, i am not trying to defend Dr. Kissinger's view point. what i want to indicate is the diversified ways to interpret history, in some cases to mislead people by distorting or disguising part of history (not refer to mutant frog here).

posted @ 7:44 PM

the 70-year-old "entrepreneurs" were shocked by questions we asked during the meeting, and one of them was so irritated that he stood up and shouted, "if you guys just want to offend our great ideas, pls go, NOW ". our friend from the local told us that we should ask our question in less direct and more tactful way, and respect these senior citizens. we are so puzzled because we believe asking the proper questions and helping them figure out what are the improvement areas of the plan is the best way to respect them.

just a reminder, we were in an inland province and all of us are from costal cities like shanghai.

we encountered similar "cultural shocks" in the following days. i feel i was in a constant process of readjusting my "rule of games" to the local one in order to fit myself into the new cultural environment. does it make sense? certainly, it works. is it less efficient? perhaps not, if everybody plays the same game rules.

posted @ 7:04 PM