via: peking duck - In China It's ******* vs. Netizens
back in late 1980s in china, there was a period during which young chinese were trying hard to convince their fathers of the dying of communism. as one of them, i was often frustrated by the fact that any testimony we offer could be turned, in a very logical way, to support their claims that "communism was thriving but had a temporary setback".
later i had an opportunity to read an article to explain such a phenomenon, it's the "language system" they use that prevent them to understand what is happening.
reading kristof, i was just wondering why the picture painted by him and the conclusions followed looks and sounds so ridiculous to me, and to many of my chinese friends, i can almost ensure you their immediate responses after reading the essay - "what a bullsh*t".
All this underscores, I think, that China is not the police state that its leaders sometimes would like it to be; the Communist Party's monopoly on information is crumbling, and its monopoly on power will follow. The Internet is chipping away relentlessly at the Party, for even 30,000 censors can't keep up with 120 million Chinese Netizens. With the Internet, China is developing for the first time in 4,000 years of history a powerful independent institution that offers checks and balances on the emperors.
"police state", "monopoly on information", "monopoly on power", "censor", "independent institution", "checks and balances", "emperors" ... well, i can't say these terms, when used individually, are not appropriate to describe and analyze the situations in china, however, when you combined them into one "language system", i find it becomes something very strange and is a useless tool to understand the reality here and predict where china will go in the future.

Pulitzer Prize Winner: Nicholas D. Kristof (The New York Times)
such a "language system", besides its self-absorbing nature, limits the dimensions of the analysis, which otherwise could offer insights or at least some new perspectives that might be more close to the reality and truth.
相关:关于 Nicholas Kristof 及其部分作品; About Nicholas D. Kristof